the Great Isaiah Scroll, the Masoretic Text and the Old Greek (GOT or "LXX") in a 3-way comparison

[Steven Avery]

  - Wallace on textual criticism....

Here, so you can see an interesting discussion, lets go back to 2010 where I discussed this Leonard Greenspoon paper, and additional sources. Since 2016 Peter J. Williams of Tyndale House has been involved in this discussion as well. ================================ KJV Only Debate Blog Was...

forums.carm.org

Here are two papers that look closely at a chapter in Isaiah and can help with a three-way comparison between the:

Great Isaiah Scroll,
Masoretic Text and
Old Greek.

=========================

Found in Translation: Essays on Jewish Biblical Translation in Honor of Leonard J. Greenspoon (2018)
The Old Greek Translation of Isaiah 40
Eugene Ulrich
https://books.google.com/books?id=Pw2yDwAAQBAJ&pg=PA113

=========================

Jesus and the Suffering Servant: Isaiah 53 and Christian Origins (2009) p. 170-192

The LXX, 1Q1sa and MT Versions of Isaiah 53 and the Christian Doctrine of Atonement
David A. Sapp

Review by H. C. Paul Kim
https://go.gale.com/ps/i.do?id=GALE...roupName=nysl_oweb&isGeoAuthType=true&aty=geo

David A. Sapp, in "The LXX, 1QIsa, and MT Versions of Isaiah 53 and the Christian Doctrine of Atonement" (pp. 170-92), detects significant textual and theological differences between the MT (along with 1QIsa) and the LXX of Isaiah 53. Comparing these versions with respect to the depiction of the fate of the Servant, Sapp verifies that the Greek texts consistently soften the stronger expressions of the Hebrew texts over the ' unjust death of a righteous Servant" (p. 184). This demonstrates the affinity of the atoning theology of the Christian Gospels to the MT in contrast with the LXX.

Extract from p. 182 - given in
Isaiah 53 and Developments in Old Testament Theology by Vincent M. Bradshaw on Academia.edu

The LXX has created a significantly different theology of the servant in Isaiah 53:8 -11 as compared to the Hebrew. In the Hebrew, the righteous one, the LORD'S servant, gives righteousness to the many through a divinely intended sacrificial death inflicted on him by wicked people ... in the LXX the LORD vindicates the righteous one who serves the many well by cutting short his agony and saving him from death at the hands of wicked people.

=========================




Last edited: 1 minute ago